Sunday, February 4, 2007


For our dinner and a movie we made sushi and watched the movie “Control Room”. Portrayed as an Iraqi perspective on the media coverage of the War on Iraq, “Control Room” is a documentary that attempts to rectify the tainted image painted by the Bush administration of the News station Al Jazeera. One point made during the movie, which I found to be extremely interesting and depressing was a comment made by the CEO of Al Jazeera that the wars today are often fought and won through the media. He went on to say that today a good general is measured by their ability to control and manipulate the media to their advantage. I could relate this to how architecture is often solely judged on images from the media, such as magazines etc. we are an image happy culture but I think us in the design world are image gluttons. And not only image gluttons but like the CEO of AL Jazeera suggested about a good general, we are image manipulator specialists. We have the abilities to render a design completely fallaciously, and like the “good general” we create these false images to win bids, competitions and clients. I realize that our ‘lies’ do not directly affect peoples lives in regards to life and death but they are still ‘lies’ and I think they should have no place in design, just as they should have no place on the battlefield.

1 comment:

Me said...

Oh, I wish I could remember the artist/architect, but I remember seeing architectural images, I think as a 'parody,' that showed the buildings as they would really exist - with homeless people panhandling, random acts of minor violence, domestic disputes, and also happier moments... Of course this is not what most clients would appreciate. I think that it is nearly impossible not to produce the lying images Judith is talking about. Clients want a dream; we try to supply it, or at least convince them that we can supply it. It's a matter of working within the system, being a player as some call it, or, maintaining the survival of your firm as others call it. I don't see architectural images as lies, but as ideal versions of what could be, in the event that the political, social, environmental (etc) contexts align in a manner that would allow the images to be physically manifested.